After a bit more refining (and discovering the usefulness of rubbing alcohol) I finally got it to the point where I liked the look. The eyes leave quite a bit to be desired, but from a moderate distance…not too shabby for scrap wood carved with an X-Acto knife.
Okay, storytime:
I’ve been working on this on and off for most of the semester, usually during a study break. Over the course of about 3 months, the wood picked up a fair bit of whatever microscopic crud was in-between the ridges of my fingerprints. So, I rubbed it with alcohol, then with a bit of laundry detergent, and scrubbed it clean. Looked like new, smelled dryer fresh.